Central Pastry Shop
Middletown · Butler County Donut Trail passport stop 2
On the passport
2 Central Pastry Shop 1518 Central Ave., Middletown, OH 45044
What the bureau's listing says
Central Pastry Shop 1518 Central Ave. Middletown OH 45044 Location: Middletown Phone (513) 423-4431
Central Pastry Shop is a full retail bakery featuring donuts, cakes, cookies, and a variety of specialty breads. Fluffy cinnamon squares, the famous "Uglies", and seasonal Paczki are just a few of the treats you can dream of at this Middletown shop. Be sure to stop and take a photo with their Donut Trail mural, and place a pin of your hometown on their Donut Trail map.
Website listed by the bureau: www.centralpastry.com
Our take written by I Ate Ohio
Central Pastry Shop, on Central Avenue in Middletown, is a full retail bakery in the bureau's description, so the case holds cakes, cookies and specialty breads as well as donuts. The listing singles out cinnamon squares, the shop's Uglies and seasonal Paczki.
It is also the trail stop with a photo spot: the bureau mentions a Donut Trail mural and a map where visitors place a pin for their hometown.
Our plain-language reading of the bureau's words quoted on this page. It adds no facts of its own.
Trail rules that apply here
At each location, ask a staff member to fill in your Passport with the official Donut Trail stamp. Visit at least a dozen shops to earn the Donut Trail T-Shirt!
Please be aware that some donut shops are closed on Sundays and Mondays, and some shops will close for the day once they sell out, even if it’s before their scheduled closing time.
Check before you go. Hours, stops and passport rules change. Confirm with Travel Butler County listing: Central Pastry Shop and Travel Butler County: Butler County Donut Trail; we last found these words there on October 14, 2026.
Other shops on this trail
The passport's order, not a ranking.