Slice of Seneca County Pizza Trail
Run by Destination Seneca County · passport trail
The stops, by town
Attica
- Smitty’s Pizza | 28 N. Main St.
- VC Attica Cameo | 23 S. Main St.
Bascom
- Sauber’s Stumble Inn | 5921 W. Tiffin St.
Fostoria
- Domino’s Pizza | 255 W. South St.
- Fostoria Pizza Palace | 1610 N County Line St.
- Marco’s Pizza | 301 N. Main St.
Green Springs
- 121 S. Broadway St (This location is no longer in business for the pizza stop, but still on the geocaching portion of the trail!)
New Riegel
- Left Field | 7889 W County Road 10
Republic
- Fat Head’s Family Restaurant | 218 Washington St.
Tiffin
- Domino’s Pizza | 240 W. Market St.
- Fort Ball Pizza Palace – North | 91 N. Washington St.
- Fort Ball Pizza Palace – South | 111 Melmore St.
- Heavenly Pizza | 69 W. Market St.
- Jac & Do’s Pizza | 283 S. Washington St.
- Marco’s Pizza | 75 Melmore St.
- Napoli Pizza | 378 W. Market St.
- Reino’s Pizza & Pasta | 73 E. Market St.
- 706 S. Sandusky St. (This location is no longer in business for the pizza stop, but still on the geocaching portion of the trail!)
As listed on Destination Seneca County: Slice of Seneca County Pizza & Geocaching Trail. Our count: 16 listed pizza stops not marked closed, and 2 addresses marked no longer in business for the pizza stop.
Our take written by I Ate Ohio
Destination Seneca County's pizza trail sends visitors to local pizzerias in towns across the county, from Attica and Fostoria to Tiffin. The page counts 18 stops; 2 of the listed addresses are marked as no longer in business for the pizza stop but still on the geocaching portion, which leaves 16 listed pizza stops not marked closed.
Five stickers earn the T-shirt, and passports are returned to the front desk of the Hampton Inn of Tiffin and nowhere else. The same passport doubles as a geocaching trail: all 19 caches earn the trail's Geocoin. The bureau notes that not every stop sells pizza by the slice.
Our plain-language reading of the bureau's words quoted on this page. It adds no facts of its own.
Passport rules
At each location, you can enjoy a pizza-related item, get your passport sticker, and enjoy your food! *Please note that not all locations on the trail offer single slice options.*
Collect at least five Slice of Seneca Pizza Trail stickers and return your completed passport to the front desk of Hampton Inn of Tiffin to redeem for your official Slice of Seneca County t-shirt! Amount required to complete for t-shirt: 5 of 18 stops
Passports can also be picked up at the Hampton Inn of Tiffin . All passports can ONLY be returned to the front desk of the Hampton Inn of Tiffin .
Complete all 19 caches and their code words and show the completed passport at the front desk of the Hampton Inn of Tiffin to receive your official Slice of Seneca County Geocoin. Amount required to complete for coin: 19 of 19 caches
Destination Seneca County hours are from 8 AM to 5 PM, Monday through Thursday, and 8 AM to 3PM on Fridays.
Check before you go. Hours, stops and passport rules change. Confirm with Destination Seneca County: Slice of Seneca County Pizza & Geocaching Trail; we last found these words there on October 14, 2026.